Skip to main content

Comparing C2B PayID, Bank Transfers, and BPAY

Consumer-to-Business (C2B) payments are essential for businesses, especially when it comes to streamlining cash flow and offering customers convenient ways to pay. In Australia, three popular options are C2B PayID, traditional bank transfers, and BPAY. Each method facilitates payments from customers to businesses, but they differ significantly in terms of speed, reconciliation, availability, and technical infrastructure. This page breaks down the key differences to help you choose the best solution for your business.

Quick Comparison Table​

FeatureC2B PayIDBank TransfersBPAY
Payment SpeedReal-time settlement, instant availability of fundsInstant if NPP-enabled; otherwise up to 1–3 days (Direct Entry)1–2 business days
Customer ExperienceSimple identifier (e.g., email with optional custom domain)Requires BSB and account numberRequires BPAY Biller Code and Reference Number
ReconciliationEasily integrated with automated tracking solutionsManual reconciliation, based on message/description/reference fieldsAutomated reconciliation with unique reference number
Availability24/7 availability via New Payments Platform (NPP)24/7 if NPP-enabled; otherwise subject to bank cut-off timesAvailable during banking hours
Ideal ForBusinesses needing real-time paymentsOne-off or infrequent transfersReusable payment details

Detailed Technical Comparison​

1. Payment Speed and Processing​

  • C2B PayID leverages the New Payments Platform (NPP) for real-time processing, providing instant fund availability. Payments are processed instantly and available to the business, without any delays.

  • Bank Transfers: Payments can be real-time if both accounts are NPP-enabled. If not, payments default to the Direct Entry (DE) system, which operates in daily batches during business hours, leading to a 1–3 day delay.

  • BPAY: Operates on a batch processing system, with transactions typically taking 1–2 business days to clear. BPAY payments are subject to set cut-off times, meaning payments initiated after the daily cut-off are delayed until the next business day.

2. Customer Experience​

  • C2B PayID uses a simple identifier for payments, such as an email address (e.g., pay@yourbusiness.com). This simplicity improves user experience and reduces errors in payment initiation.

  • Bank Transfers: Customers must enter BSB and account number, a process that can be cumbersome and prone to errors if details are incorrect.

  • BPAY: Requires a BPAY Biller Code and Reference Number. Ideal for recurring payments but can be less streamlined for one-time transactions.

Real-Time Validation of Amounts

One key advantage of C2B PayID is its ability to provide real-time validation of payment amounts. PayID-enabled systems can instantly verify amounts received, helping detect underpayments or overpayments and enabling quick corrective action.

3. Reconciliation and Data Management​

  • C2B PayID: Supports automated reconciliation with customisable tracking tools, matching incoming payments to invoices in real-time.

  • Bank Transfers: Typically requires manual reconciliation. Effectiveness depends on customer input in the reference fields, with advanced options requiring custom configurations.

  • BPAY: Provides a unique reference number for each transaction, making reconciliation straightforward and efficient. Ideal for industries with high reliance on automated tracking.

4. Availability and Infrastructure​

  • C2B PayID: Available 24/7 on the NPP, supporting instant payments any time, including weekends and holidays, ensuring consistent cash flow.

  • Bank Transfers: Availability varies. NPP-enabled transfers are available 24/7, while DE transfers operate during business hours with a cut-off time (typically 4 PM AEST).

  • BPAY: Available during regular banking hours, with a batch processing system that delays payments initiated after daily cut-off times until the next business day.

5. Ideal Use Cases​

  • C2B PayID: Suited for businesses needing real-time payments with a streamlined customer experience. Best for e-commerce, professional services, and industries with frequent transactions.

  • Bank Transfers: Suitable for one-off or infrequent payments. Familiar but may require more reconciliation support for accurate tracking.

  • BPAY: Perfect for recurring payments like utility bills, subscriptions, and other regular expenses due to reliable automated reconciliation.